Did you know that 82% of buyers accept meetings when initiated by a cold call? That's a pretty compelling statistic, but don't hang up on your cold emails just yet.

Cold calling and cold emailing are two heavy-hitters in the sales world, but which one really packs a punch? We'll break down the pros, cons, and when to use each, so you can stop guessing and start connecting.

Here's what we'll cover:

• The nitty-gritty of cold calling and cold emailing
• Strengths and weaknesses of each approach
• When to dial it up or fire off an email
• Alternative strategies for maximum impact
• Success rates and how to boost yours

P.S. Whether it’s a cold email or cold call, you’ll need emails that don’t bounce and phone numbers that aren’t dead ends. ListKit arms you with triple-verified contact information of your ideal client profile so that your cold outreach efforts don’t go unnoticed. 

Cold Calling vs. Cold Emailing: A Head-to-Head Comparison

What Exactly Is Cold Calling Anyway?

Cold calling is the sales equivalent of walking up to a stranger at a party and launching into your elevator pitch. It's the technique of contacting potential customers who haven't expressed any prior interest in your product or service.

Imagine dialing up a number you found online, hoping the person on the other end is interested in what you're selling and willing to listen to you for a few minutes. It's a bold move, and it's not for the faint of heart. But when done right, cold calling can be an incredibly effective way to generate leads and close deals.

What cold calling is best known for

Cold calling has a bit of a reputation, and not always a good one. It's notorious for:

• The element of surprise: Your call is often unexpected (and sometimes unwanted), which can either spark curiosity or irritation.
• The need for thick skin: Brace yourself for rejection. It's part of the game.
• The potential for high reward: When a cold call clicks, it can lead to a lucrative business relationship.
• The need for a killer script: You need to hook your prospect quickly and keep them engaged.
• The fear factor: Many sales reps dread cold calling, but those who master it become invaluable assets.

Now, you might be wondering if cold calling is still relevant in today's digital age. Is it worth the time and effort when you could be sending out emails or connecting on social media? Well, that's a question worth exploring...

The Pros and Cons of Cold Calling

Cold calling is not all sunshine and rainbows. It's got its fair share of pros and cons. Let's take a closer look:

The good: Why cold calling can be a game-changer

• Direct connection: Forget the inbox clutter. Cold calling gets you a real-time conversation with your prospect. This allows you to build rapport, address concerns on the spot, and potentially close the deal faster.
• Immediate feedback: Unlike emails that might get lost in the void, cold calling gives cold callers instant feedback. You'll know right away if your pitch is resonating or if you need to change tactics.
• Opportunity for persuasion: Got the gift of gab? Cold calling lets you flex your persuasive muscles, using your voice and personality to influence the prospect.
• Personalization: You can tailor your pitch on the fly, adapting to the prospect's responses and needs.
• Qualification: You can quickly qualify leads, determining if they're a good fit for your product or service and saving you time in the long run.

The not-so-good: The challenges of cold calling

• High rejection rate: Get ready to hear "no" a lot. It's a numbers game, and not everyone will be receptive to your call.
• Time-consuming: Cold calling can be a time suck, especially if you're not reaching the right people.
• Interruptions: You're catching people in the middle of their workday, which might not always be the best time.
• Gatekeepers: Administrative assistants and receptionists can be a tough crowd to please.
• Negative perception: Some people view cold calling as intrusive and annoying, which can damage your brand's reputation.

So, is cold calling worth it? It depends. If you have a thick skin, a knack for persuasion, and a solid list of qualified leads, it can be a valuable tool in your sales arsenal. But if you're short on time and patience, or if your target audience is particularly averse to cold calls, there might be better options out there.

Cold Calling Criteria Evaluation

Before you dial that number, let's assess cold calling through a critical lens. We'll rate key criteria on a scale of 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) to give you a clearer picture.

What Is Cold Emailing

Cold emailing is the digital cousin of cold calling. Instead of picking up the phone, you're crafting a persuasive email to reach potential customers who haven't interacted with your brand before.

Picture this: you've got a targeted list of prospects (more on how to get those later), and you're sending them a well-crafted email that introduces yourself and your product or service. It's like a virtual handshake, a way to spark a conversation and potentially turn a stranger into a customer.

What cold emailing is best known for

Cold emailing has its own quirks and characteristics:

• Scalability: Reach hundreds or even thousands of prospects with a single click. No dialing required.
• Convenience: Send emails on your schedule, not when your prospects are (hopefully) available to talk.
• Measurability: Track open rates, click-through rates, and other metrics to see what's working and what's not.
• Automation: Set up automated email sequences to nurture leads over time.
• Less intrusive: Some people find emails less disruptive than phone calls. (But be careful not to overdo it with the emails, or you'll end up in the spam folder faster than you can say "unsubscribe.")

Just like cold calling, cold emailing has its own set of challenges and advantages.

The Pros and Cons of Cold Emailing

Cold emailing isn't a magic bullet, but it's not a dud either. Here's the good, the bad, and the ugly of this popular outreach method:

The good: Why cold emailing can be a lead-gen powerhouse

• Scalability and efficiency: Cold emailing is your ticket to reaching a vast audience in a short amount of time. Imagine effortlessly contacting hundreds or even thousands of potential customers with just a few clicks. That's the power of scalability.
• Cost-effectiveness: Ditch the expensive call centers and dialing systems. Cold emailing is a budget-friendly option that won't break the bank. You just need a killer email list (hint: ListKit can help with that) and a well-crafted message.
• Measurable results: Unlike the mystery of unanswered phone calls, cold emailing offers a treasure trove of data. Track open rates, click-through rates, and conversions to fine-tune your approach and optimize your results.
• Personalization at scale: While not as personal as a one-on-one conversation, cold emails can still be tailored to your audience. Use merge tags to address recipients by name, segment your list based on interests, and personalize your message for maximum impact.
• Non-intrusive: Let's face it, most people prefer an email over an unexpected phone call. Cold emails give your prospects the freedom to read and respond at their convenience, making them a less disruptive outreach method.

The not-so-good: The challenges of cold emailing

• Low open and response rates: It's a harsh reality: most cold emails don't get opened, and even fewer get a response. You'll need a compelling subject line and a strong value proposition to cut through the noise.
• Deliverability issues: Landing in the spam folder is a cold emailer's worst nightmare. Avoid spam trigger words, personalize your messages, and use a reputable email sending tool like Smartlead to improve your chances of reaching the inbox.
• Building a quality email list: A bad email list is a recipe for disaster. You need accurate, up-to-date contact information for your ideal customers. ListKit can be a lifesaver here, providing you with a vast database of triple-verified leads to supercharge your outreach.
• Standing out in a crowded inbox: Your prospects are bombarded with emails every day. Your message needs to be exceptional to grab their attention and get them to take action.

So, is cold emailing right for you? That depends on your goals, resources, and target audience. If you're looking for a scalable, cost-effective way to reach a large audience, it can be a powerful tool. But if you're expecting instant results or a personal touch, you can still do it but without automation. There's a better strategy for this called account-based marketing.

No matter which path you choose, remember that both cold calling and cold emailing are just tools in your sales toolbox. The key is to use them strategically, tailoring your approach to the specific needs and preferences of your target audience.

‍

Evaluating Cold Emailing

Cold emailing might seem like a no-brainer in the digital age, but let's take a closer look at its pros and cons based on key criteria. We'll rate them on a scale of 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent) to help you make an informed decision.

Alternative Lead Generation Strategies

Cold calling and cold emailing aren't the only players in the lead generation game. While they can be effective, sometimes you need a different approach to reel in those high-value prospects. Let's explore two powerful alternatives:

Account-Based Marketing (ABM)

Tired of casting a wide net and hoping for the best? ABM takes a more targeted approach, focusing your efforts on specific, high-value accounts that are most likely to convert into customers.

Think of it as a personalized marketing campaign for each individual account. You're not just sending out generic messages; you're tailoring your outreach to the specific needs, pain points, and interests of each company. This level of personalization can lead to higher engagement, stronger relationships, and ultimately, more closed deals.

Integrated Multichannel Campaigns

Why limit yourself to one channel when you can leverage the power of many? Integrated multichannel campaigns combine various outreach methods (think email, social media, content marketing, paid ads, and even events) to create a cohesive and engaging experience for your prospects.

It's like a symphony orchestra, with each instrument playing its part to create a harmonious melody. By using multiple channels, you can reach your audience where they're most active, reinforce your message, and nurture leads throughout the buyer's journey.

Why ABM and Multichannel campaigns are worth considering:

• Higher ROI: By focusing on high-value accounts and using a multi-pronged approach, you can maximize your return on investment and drive more revenue.
• Stronger relationships: Personalized outreach and consistent messaging across channels can help you build deeper connections with your prospects.
• Improved lead quality: Targeting specific accounts and tailoring your message can attract more qualified leads who are genuinely interested in your product or service.

Ready to get started with these alternative strategies? But before we do, let's talk about how ListKit can supercharge your efforts in both areas.

Here's how ListKit can be a game-changer for ABM and multichannel campaigns:

• Targeted Account Selection: ListKit's robust search filters and data analytics help you identify your ideal customer profiles (ICPs) with laser precision. You can target accounts based on firmographics, technographics, and even website traffic patterns.
• Building High-Quality Lists: ABM relies on reaching the right people within your target accounts. ListKit's verified contact information ensures your outreach lands in the inboxes of key decision-makers, not spam filters or folders.
• Personalization at Scale: Multichannel campaigns thrive on personalization. ListKit's data enrichment features allow you to personalize your messages with relevant details, making your outreach more impactful.
• Streamlined Campaign Management: ListKit integrates seamlessly with popular marketing automation and CRM platforms. This lets you manage your ABM and multichannel campaigns efficiently, saving you time and resources.

‍

What's Considered a "Good" Success Rate for Cold Outreach?

Let's talk numbers. What can you realistically expect from your cold calling and cold emailing efforts? While success rates vary depending on your industry, target audience, and the quality of your outreach, here are some benchmarks to keep in mind:

Cold calling success rates

• Average: 1-3% (This means you can expect 1-3 positive responses for every 100 calls you make.)
• Good: 5-10%
• Excellent: 10%+

Cold emailing success rates

• Average: 1-5% (This translates to 1-5 replies for every 100 emails you send.)
• Good: 5-10%
• Excellent: 10%+

These are just averages, and your results may vary. But it's important to set realistic expectations and track your progress over time.

Pro tip: Don't just focus on response rates. Look at the quality of your responses. Are you getting replies from decision-makers? Are they expressing genuine interest in your product or service? These are the metrics that matter most.

A low response rate doesn't necessarily mean your outreach is failing. It could simply mean you need to refine your targeting, messaging, or timing. Don't be afraid to experiment and try different approaches to see what works best for your audience.

Tips to Boost Your Cold Email Success Rate

Ready to turn those cold emails into warm leads? Here's how to boost your open, response, and conversion rates:

1. Craft a killer subject line

Your subject line is the first impression your email makes. Make it count. Keep it short, snappy, and intriguing. Use personalization, quick action, numbers, or a touch of humor to pique curiosity.

• "Quick question"
• "question about {company}"
• "question for {name}"
• "{name} + YOUR NAME"
• "{company} + YOUR COMPANY"

Read more: 21 Killer Cold Email Subject Lines (91% Open Rates)

2. Personalize, personalize, personalize

Don't just send a generic email blast. Address your recipients by name, reference their company or industry, and tailor your message to their specific needs and pain points.

• Pro tip: Use ListKit to gather valuable data on your prospects, including their job titles, company size, and recent activities. This will help you personalize your emails like a pro.

3. Keep it short and sweet

Nobody wants to read a novel in their inbox. Get to the point quickly, highlight the key benefits of your product or service, and include a clear call to action.

• Example: "Could [your product/service] solve [pain point]? Let's chat for 15 minutes to find out."

4. Provide value upfront

Don't just talk about yourself and your company. Offer something of value to your prospect. Share a relevant article, a free trial of your product, or a quick tip related to their industry.

• Pro tip: Use a tool like Smartlead to track which links in your emails are getting clicked. This will help you understand what type of content resonates with your audience.

5. Follow up (but don't be a pest)

Don't give up after one email. Send a well-timed follow-up email (or two) to remind your prospect of your offer and keep the conversation going.

• Example: "Just checking in to see if you had a chance to review my previous email. Happy to answer any questions you might have."

6. A/B test your emails

Don't just guess what works. Experiment with different subject lines, email copy, calls to action, and sending times to see what gets the best results.

• Pro tip: Use a tool like Smartlead to easily A/B test your cold emails and track your results. This will help you continuously improve your outreach and boost your success rate.

7. Leverage social proof

If you have case studies, testimonials, or positive reviews, don't be afraid to showcase them in your emails. Social proof can add credibility to your message and encourage prospects to take action.

• Example: "See how [company name] increased their revenue by 20% using our platform."

8. Ensure High Deliverability

• This is an extremely important point, and we put it at the end so you remember it especially. Ensure your emails reach the inbox and not the spam folder. Use tools to verify email addresses, warm up your email domain, and monitor your sender reputation.
  • Tools like ListKit triple-verifies emails and phone numbers for you, and Smartlead lets you auto warm-up your domains in bulk for 7-14 days before you start any campaign.

Tips for Cold Calling Success

Don't let cold calling be a cold shoulder. These tips will help you turn those dreaded dials into delightful conversations and closed deals:

1. Perfect your opening line

Your first few seconds on the phone are crucial. Grab their attention with a strong opening line that piques their interest and makes them want to hear more.

• Example: "Hi [Name], I noticed that your company recently [accomplishment/event]. Congratulations! I have an idea that could help you [benefit]."

2. Research your prospects

Don't go in blind. Learn everything you can about your prospects before you call. Check out their website, LinkedIn profile, and recent news articles to understand their needs, challenges, and goals.

• Pro tip: Use ListKit to access detailed information on your prospects, including their job titles, company size, industry, and recent activities. This will help you tailor your pitch to their specific situation.
• ‍

3. Build rapport

Cold calling doesn't have to be cold. Be friendly, personable, and genuinely interested in your prospect. Ask open-ended questions, actively listen to their responses, and find common ground.

• Example: "How's your day going? I know you're probably busy, so I'll be brief."

4. Focus on benefits, not features

Don't just rattle off a list of your product's features. Explain how those features can solve your prospect's problems and make their life easier.

• Example: "Our software can help you save 20% on your marketing budget by automating repetitive tasks."

5. Handle objections with grace

Don't get discouraged by objections. View them as opportunities to learn more about your prospect's needs and address their concerns.

• Example: "I understand your hesitation. Many of our clients felt the same way at first, but they were pleasantly surprised by the results. Would you be open to hearing a quick case study?"

6. Have a strong closing statement

Don't leave the conversation hanging. Summarize the key points of your pitch and clearly state the next steps.

• Example: "Based on what you've told me, I believe our product could be a great fit for your company. Would you be available for a 30-minute demo next week?"

7. Practice, practice, practice

Cold calling is a skill, and like any skill, it takes practice to master. Role-play with colleagues, record yourself, and get feedback to improve your technique.

• Pro tip: Use a tool like Smartlead to record and analyze your cold calls. This will help you identify areas for improvement and track your progress over time.

8. Use a CRM to track your calls

Don't just wing it. Use a CRM (Customer Relationship Management) system to keep track of your calls, notes, and follow-up tasks. This will help you stay organized and ensure that no leads fall through the cracks.

Cold Calling or Cold Emailing?

Knowing when to use cold calling versus cold emailing is key to unlocking their full potential. Let's break down the ideal scenarios for each approach:

When to cold email:

• Large-scale outreach: Need to reach a massive audience quickly? Cold emailing is your go-to. It's the most efficient way to contact hundreds or even thousands of prospects in a short amount of time.
• Lead nurturing: Cold emails are perfect for warming up leads and building relationships over time. Use automated email sequences to deliver valuable content, share relevant resources, and gradually guide prospects through the sales funnel.
• Following up: After an initial contact (whether it was a cold call, a networking event, or a social media interaction), a well-crafted cold email can keep the conversation going and move the deal forward.
• Promoting content: Have a new blog post, whitepaper, or webinar? Cold emailing can be a great way to get it in front of potential customers and drive traffic to your website.
• Targeting specific industries: If your product or service caters to a specific niche, cold emailing allows you to laser-focus your outreach and reach the right people with the right message.

When to pick up the phone and make that call?

• High-value deals: If you're pursuing a big deal with a high potential for revenue, a cold call can be a more impactful way to make a personal connection and build rapport with the decision-maker.

• Complex sales: When your product or service requires a detailed explanation or a live demo, a cold call allows you to answer questions in real-time and address any concerns the prospect might have.
• Time-sensitive offers: If you have a limited-time promotion or a time-sensitive offer, a cold call can create a sense of urgency and encourage the prospect to take action quickly.
• Building relationships: While challenging, cold calling can be an effective way to establish a personal connection with your prospect. A genuine conversation can go a long way in building trust and rapport.
• Breaking through the noise: If your competitors are relying heavily on email outreach, a well-executed cold call can help you stand out from the crowd and get your message heard.

The verdict? It's not an either/or situation

The truth is, cold calling and cold emailing don't have to be mutually exclusive. In fact, they can work together in perfect harmony to create a powerful outreach strategy. Use cold emails to cast a wide net, nurture leads, and follow up on the prior contact. Then, use cold calling to seal the deal with high-value prospects, build relationships, and tackle complex sales.

‍

Combine Cold Emailing and Cold Calling in Perfect Harmony

Imagine a well-orchestrated symphony where cold emails and cold calls work together seamlessly, creating a powerful melody of lead generation and sales conversions. It's not a pipe dream; it's a strategy that savvy businesses are using to crush their outreach goals.

Here's how cold emailing and cold calling can complement each other like peanut butter and jelly:

1. Warm up with email, connect with a call: Start by sending a personalized cold email to introduce yourself and pique the prospect's interest. Then, follow up with a phone call to deepen the connection, answer questions, and build rapport. This approach combines the scalability of email with the personal touch of a phone conversation.
2. Email for nurturing, call for closing: Use email sequences to nurture leads, share valuable content, and build trust over time. Then, when the prospect is warmed up and engaged, swoop in with a well-timed call to close the deal. This strategy leverages the strengths of both channels to guide prospects through the entire sales funnel.
3. Tailored outreach for different personas: Not all prospects are the same. Some might prefer email communication, while others might be more receptive to a phone call. Use ListKit to segment your audience based on their preferences and tailor your outreach accordingly. This ensures that you're communicating with each prospect in the way they prefer.
4. Multichannel touchpoints for maximum impact: Don't just rely on email and phone calls. Integrate social media, content marketing, and paid advertising into your outreach strategy. This creates multiple touchpoints with your prospects, increasing brand awareness and reinforcing your message.

  Pro tip: Use a tool like Expandi for LinkedIn automation to streamline your cold outreach efforts. Expandi can help you automate connection requests, send   personalized messages, and even track your results. It's like having a virtual assistant for your LinkedIn outreach.

        5. Track your email open rates, click-through rates, call outcomes, and conversion data to gain valuable insights into what's working and what's not. Use this data to         refine your approach, optimize your messaging, and improve your overall outreach effectiveness.

The result?

By combining the strengths of cold emailing and cold calling, you can:

• Increase your reach: Reach a wider audience and generate more leads.
• Improve engagement: Spark conversations and build relationships with prospects.
• Boost conversions: Move prospects through the sales funnel and close more deals.
• Maximize ROI: Get the most out of your sales and marketing efforts.

Ready to take your outreach to the next level? It's time to combine cold emailing and cold calling.

Close Your Next Client With ListKit

Whether you're dialing up a storm or crafting the perfect email, the best outreach strategy is the one that works for your business and your customers. Experiment, adapt, and find the winning combination that helps you connect, convert, and conquer.

Key takeaways:

• Cold call and cold email campaigns each have their own strengths and weaknesses.
• Choose the right tool for the job based on your goals, resources, and target audience.
• Don't be afraid to combining cold calling and cold emailing for a multi-pronged approach.
• Track your results and adjust your strategy as needed.

Speaking of tracking results and adjusting strategies, have you met ListKit yet? It's the ultimate B2B lead database, packed with triple-verified leads to supercharge your cold outreach game. Whether you're dialing up a storm or hitting the inbox, ListKit gives you the data and insights you need to connect with your ideal customers and turn cold leads into hot deals.

FAQs

Can cold calling and cold emailing be combined for better results?

Absolutely. In fact, they make a dynamic duo. Start with a personalized email to warm up your prospect, then follow up with a phone call to build rapport and close the deal. You can also use email for nurturing and sales calls for high-value deals. The key is to tailor your approach to each prospect's preferences and use both channels strategically.

What are the best practices for successful cold calling?

• Research your prospects thoroughly.
• Craft a compelling opening line that grabs attention.
• Focus on benefits, not features.
• Ask open-ended questions and actively listen.
• Handle objections with grace and confidence.
• Have a strong closing statement and clear next steps.
• Practice your pitch and get feedback.
• Use a CRM to track your calls and follow-up tasks.

What are the legal and compliance considerations for cold outreach?

Cold outreach is subject to various regulations, such as the CAN-SPAM Act for email and the TCPA for phone calls. It's crucial to familiarize yourself with these regulations and ensure your outreach practices are compliant. This includes obtaining consent for email marketing, honoring unsubscribe requests, and respecting "Do Not Call" lists.

How can I measure the success and ROI of my cold outreach campaigns?

Track key metrics like open rates, click-through rates, response rates, conversion rates, and revenue generated. Use a tool like Smartlead to track your cold outreach campaign and integrate your cold calling data with your CRM. Analyze the data to identify what's working and what's not, then adjust your strategy accordingly. Remember, it's an ongoing process of testing, refining, and optimizing.

‍